Grill Talk: Dishing on Flat Top Grill vs Regular Grill

Flat Top Grill vs Regular Grill

Getting to Know Flat Top Grills

Flat top grills are the secret weapon for BBQ lovers like me. They open up a world of cooking possibilities without the hassle.

Versatile Cooking Fun

Flat top grills have a smooth steel surface that’s fantastic for cooking a variety of foods. I can whip up smash burgers, pancakes, fried eggs, and stir fry all at once. The controllable cooking zones let you cook different foods at the perfect temps (Tom’s Guide).

Here’s a quick look at what you can do with flat top grill vs regular grill:

TechniqueFlat TopRegular
GrillingMeats and moreMostly meats
SearingExcellentGood
Breakfast FoodsIdealLimited
Stir FryPerfectNope
FryingEasy and quickNope

Having the whole griddle to work with opens up endless meal options.

Benefits Galore

Why do I love my flat top grill? Let me count the ways:


  1. Non-Stick Ease: Season the surface right, and you won’t be scraping stuck food. Cleanup is a breeze.



  2. Simple Cleaning: Forget those annoying grates. Just wipe down the flat surface and you’re done.



  3. Big Cooking Surface: More room means more food at once. Great for cooking for a crowd.



  4. Variety of Cooking: Grilling, searing, frying, and making breakfast—all on one grill. The possibilities are endless. Check out some of my favorite flat top grill recipes.


With a flat top grill, I’ve taken my outdoor cooking to another level, and I can’t recommend it enough. Try it out and see how it can change your BBQ game.

Getting Started with Flat Top Grills

Flat top grilling is like discovering a whole new cooking world. Let’s get your griddle prepped and point out some essential gear to make your culinary adventures top notch.

Seasoning Your Griddle

Seasoning your flat-top griddle is a must. Don’t skip it. It’s all about creating a slick, non-stick surface. Here’s my go-to method: slather on a neutral oil, then crank up the heat until the oil smokes. You’ll see the surface change from dull gray to shiny black – this can take an hour if you’ve got a big one like the Traeger Flatrock (Tom’s Guide).

Here’s a quick and easy guide:

StepActionTime Required
1Slather on neutral oil5 minutes
2Heat until it starts smoking1 hour
3Let it cool10 minutes
4Rinse and repeat if needed

This seasoning not only safeguards your griddle but also amps up the flavour of whatever you cook.

Essential Griddle Accessories

To get the best out of your flat-top grill, having the right gear is key. Here’s what’s in my arsenal:

AccessoryWhy You Need It
Griddle SpatulasFlip and serve like a pro
TongsHandy for meats and veggies
Oil Squirt BottlesPrecise oil application
Scrub BrushScrubbing off the grime
ScraperRemoving stuck-on bits
Cast-Iron Burger PressEvenly cooking your patties
Melting DomePerfectly melting cheese and trapping heat

These tools not only make cooking smoother but also help keep your grill clean, which is crucial for longevity (cleaning a flat top grill).

Whether you’re whipping up some amazing flat top grill recipes or trying out new tricks, having a well-seasoned griddle and the right tools makes it all the more fun. Check out some flat top grilling tips to up your game even more.

Flat Top Grill vs Regular Grill

On my quest to become an outdoor cooking master, I’ve gotten my hands dirty with both flat top grills and traditional grills. Each one has its quirks, and knowing their differences can help grill enthusiasts like us make the best choice for their backyard feasts.

Cooking Methods Compared

When it comes to cooking, it’s not just about the heat—it’s how you use it. Here’s a no-frills comparison:

What to Look AtFlat Top GrillRegular Grill
Style of CookingFlat surface for direct heatGrates for cooking over flames
Heat SourceGas or electricGas or charcoal
Food PlacementCook multiple items at onceNeeds careful placement
Cooking TechniquesSautéing, frying, searingGrilling, smoking, charring

With a flat top grill, you can sauté, fry, and even make pancakes, eggs, or stir-fries alongside your favorite meats. It’s like having your kitchen outside.

Traditional grills, on the other hand, bring that smoky flavour you can’t get anywhere else. The direct flames and grill marks make those steaks and burgers taste divine (Drizzle Me Skinny).

Pros and Cons

Both grill types have their perks and pitfalls. Here’s what I’ve found:

AspectFlat Top Grill ProsFlat Top Grill ConsRegular Grill ProsRegular Grill Cons
Even CookingEven heat distributionNot much smokinessSmoky flavour and those perfect grill marksUneven cooking sometimes
VersatilityCooks a variety of dishesCan be a pain to cleanPerfect for high-heat dishesGetting that temperature just right
Ease of UseSimple controls with no guessworkMisses that classic charFlames make quick cooking easyTiming and placement can be tricky
Cooking SurfaceLarge surface for multiple itemsTakes time to preheatGreat for cooking a bunch in one goBig and bulky, might hog your yard space

Flat top grills might miss that smoky punch, but when it comes to versatility and one-pan miracles, they’re a win. Traditional grills, on the other hand, give you those charred, smoky bites but need your full attention to get it just right.

At the end of the day, your grill choice boils down to whatever suits your cooking style. Whether you’re experimenting with stir-fries on the flat top or enjoying the smoky goodness from a traditional grill, both have their moments to shine. Ready to try your hand at some tasty flat top grill recipes? I promise you won’t be disappointed!

Flat Top Grill vs Regular Grill article image

Rocking the Flat Top Grill

Cranking up a flat top grill isn’t just for flipping burgers. This griddle can transform your cooking game, making everything from searing steaks to whipping up stir-fry a breeze. With its sprawling surface and controllable heat zones, you’re set to surprise your taste buds.

Nailing Those Temperatures

Getting the right temperature was a game-changer for my grill sessions. After tweaking the settings, I found that 148°C to 204°C (300°F to 400°F) is my happy place for most dishes. This range avoids the dreaded burn and nails that perfect caramelization. Here’s my go-to temp guide:

Cooking StyleSweet Spot °C – (°F)
Searing204 – 232 (400 – 450)
Stir Fry176 – 204 (350 – 400)
Pancakes176 (350)
Smash Burgers204 – 232 (400 – 450)

With controllable zones, you can keep the chicken warm while searing veggies, making your Sunday BBQ a hit.

My Grill Hacks


  1. Season It Right: I swear by seasoning. It’s like prepping the grill’s soul. It ensures nothing sticks and flavours pop. Check out our guide on seasoning your flat top for a hassle-free start.



  2. Less Oil = More Flavour: After that initial seasoning, go easy on oil. A smidge of butter or oil does the trick without drowning your food (Tom’s Guide).



  3. Preppin’ Like a Pro: Chop those veggies, marinate the proteins, and get your mise en place ready before heating up the grill. This prep-work is a lifesaver, letting you ace the cooking part.



  4. Flip Like a Boss: Flipping isn’t just for show. With a metal spatula, practice makes perfect, especially for dishes like smash burgers or pancakes that tend to crumble.



  5. Stay Clean, Cook Mean: Cleaning as you cook keeps the flavours coming and avoids gunk buildup. I keep a spatula close to scrape off stickies. For a deep clean after, peek at our cleaning tips.



  6. Recipe Roulette: Boredom doesn’t stand a chance. A flat top grill lets you get creative, from breakfast eggs to dinner stir-fries. Dive into our recipe ideas and mix it up.



  7. Thermometer Love: A solid meat thermometer is my kitchen wingman. It takes the guesswork out and ensures perfectly cooked steaks every time.


Following these hacks, my flat top grilling sessions have become more fun and flavourful. It’s all about enjoying the process and serving up meals that get everyone talking.

Keeping Your Flat Top Grill in Top Shape

Taking care of your flat top grill isn’t just about keeping it looking good; it’s about ensuring it serves up tasty meals and lasts for years. Proper cleaning and maintenance can make a huge difference in its performance over time.

Cleaning and Longevity

Cleaning your flat top grill will keep it running smoothly. Letting food build up on the surface not only makes future clean-ups tougher, but it can also mess with the grill’s cooking surface. A dirty griddle can lead to uneven cooking and weird flavours in your food, which nobody wants.

Grills like the Carbon Steel Griddle offer a naturally nonstick surface. This not only makes cleaning easier but also saves you from scraping burnt food off the grates usually found on a regular grill.

TaskHow Often?
Wipe down post-cookingAfter each use
Deep clean surfaceWeekly
Re-season the griddleMonthly

Simple Ways to Care for Your Grill

To keep your flat top grill performing at its best, follow some straightforward steps. Start by removing any food scraps after cooking. While the grill is still warm, scrape off debris with a spatula—trust me, it’s way easier then.

For a deeper clean, use mild detergent and water. If some pesky food bits won’t come off, a specialized cleaning tool can help. Just avoid anything too abrasive, or you might damage that precious cooking surface.

Flat top grills distribute heat evenly, so you can cook with minimal fat. Grease and juices evaporate off the hot plate, making clean-up a breeze.

After cleaning, season your griddle to maintain its nonstick magic. A thin layer of oil, heated until absorbed, does the trick. For more detailed steps, check out our guide on how to season a flat top grill.

By keeping your flat top grill clean and well-maintained, you’ll ensure it continues to serve up delicious meals for every BBQ. Plus, you can focus on cooking and having fun with friends and family instead of worrying about grill issues.

Picking Your Perfect Grill

Grill shopping can be a blast, but let’s keep it real – there’s a lot to think about. Whether you’re new to grilling or an old hand, the best fit depends on how you cook, what you cook, and where you cook. Here’s my take on what you need to look at to find your grill soulmate.

What to Look For


  1. Fuel Source: Think about what fires you up – do you prefer gas, electric, or charcoal? Each has its vibes and quirks.



  2. Size: Space and crowd are huge. Got a big backyard and lots of buddies? You might want a large grill. For smaller spaces or solo sessions, think compact.



  3. BTU Rating: BTUs tell you how much muscle your grill’s got. Higher BTUs mean it heats up fast and cooks with power.



  4. Extras: Side burners, temp controls, wheels – these gadgets can make your grilling game smoother.


FactorWhat’s The Deal?
Fuel SourceGas, Electric, Charcoal
SizeHow much room ya got? Cooking for many or few?
BTU RatingMore BTUs = More Heat
ExtrasStuff like side burners, portability, and temp control

Keep these points in mind and match them to how you like to cook. It’s a recipe for grilling greatness.

Gas vs. Electric vs. Charcoal Grills

Grills are like people – they’ve all got their personalities. Here’s a look at what each type brings to the BBQ table:

Gas Grills

Gas grills are backyard favorites. They’re like the reliable friend who’s always on time and ready for action. They heat up fast, and you get those Instagram-worthy grill marks. Great for quick, high-heat cooking – think steaks and burgers. Check out RTA Outdoor Living if ya want the pro scoop.

Electric Grills

Electric grills? They’re the easy-breezy cousins of the grill world. No fuss with gas or charcoal – just plug in and go. They’re super handy for indoor/outdoor setups and shine with foods that need steady heat. Not the best for searing, but they nail the even-cook game (Grill Masters Club).

Charcoal Grills

Ah, the charcoal grill – the old-school flavour king. It’s all about that smoky goodness. They take patience and practice – lighting the coals and managing the heat – but the taste pays off. Think of it like a culinary workout with a delicious reward at the end.

When it comes to choosing flat top grills versus other types, it’s all about what fits you. Each grill type brings something unique, from the gas grill’s speed to the charcoal grill’s flavour journey. Find your match, fire it up, and get ready for some epic grilling sessions.

Similar Posts